PLL: Unique Sin: Who’s Imogen’s Child’s Father?


HBO Max’s “Fairly Little Liars: Unique Sin” has concluded its first season, and we’re nonetheless not over among the most surprising finale revelations. Even with the driving thriller of the masked menace “A” lurking dangerously near the brand new ensemble of Liars, a number of working questions within the story stored the viewers’ consideration as effectively, particularly the enigma surrounding Imogen’s (Bailee Madison) being pregnant, for example. It is revealed all through the season that Imogen’s being pregnant is the results of a sexual assault. Her closest buddy, Tabby, was additionally just lately sexually assaulted, which — sadly — was not a coincidence.

So who’s Imogen’s attacker and the daddy of her unborn youngster? All of the solutions are forward.

What Occurred the Night time Imogen Was Sexually Assaulted?

After the one-month time soar following her mom’s demise, Imogen returns to Millwood Excessive, at which level she’s now six months into her being pregnant. On her first day again, when her classmates press her for extra particulars in regards to the father, she says he was a lifeguard however shouldn’t be within the image. The scene then cuts to a flashback of Imogen sitting alone on the seashore with a liquor bottle beside her, staring forward deep in thought.

Within the fleeting sequence, Imogen is sporting a blue costume and matching cardigan — the identical outfit she wore to Karen Beasley’s home celebration. You will keep in mind Imogen and Karen ended up arguing on the celebration over Karen’s boyfriend, Greg, kissing Imogen, at which level Karen kicked her out. In episode 5, Imogen reveals she blacked out after leaving the celebration and awoke on the seashore, discovering she’d been sexually assaulted. That was the night time her child was conceived, so Imogen doesn’t know the attacker’s identification.

Who Is Imogen’s Child’s Father? Chip

Tabby’s buddy, filming associate, and theater coworker Chip looks as if essentially the most superb human all through season one. He listens to Tabby and all the time tries to do proper by her, and though it is clear he has some unrequited emotions for her, he by no means, ever crosses the road (in contrast to Tabby’s creepy boss, Wes). Nicely, so far as viewers know at first.

Whereas, at first, Chip would not do something to outwardly counsel he is something however an superior buddy, he is nearly too superior. Tabby turns to Chip consistently to assist her with schemes, and straight-up admits she’ll solely go to the dance with him if he agrees to help her in embarrassing Karen in entrance of the entire college (which, oddly, he agrees to). Whereas Tabby has no obligation to love Chip as something greater than a buddy, when contemplating his unrequited emotions for her, his degree of endurance with the generally self-involved antics appears nearly caricature-like — particularly when the digicam lingers on him for a beat too lengthy after their interactions.

Because the season progresses, it is revealed Tabby was sexually assaulted in the identical method Imogen was, on the night time she went to a celebration within the woods. As the ladies recount their experiences collectively, it is revealed Chip knew she was going to the celebration and received indignant on the thought of her hanging out with soccer gamers, however she would not put the items collectively simply but.

It isn’t till episode 9 that Tabby begins to comprehend one thing’s not proper with Chip. He has flashes of unreasonable jealousy and will get territorial when she reveals she and Wes kissed. She additionally remembers Chip leaving Karen’s celebration drunk and upset after she rejected his advances earlier that 12 months. Then, Wes reveals to her that Chip ditched work the night time she went to the celebration within the woods. Suspecting Chip, she and Imogen go to his home to try to discover proof he raped them, solely to uncover a field stuffed with what Tabby calls “rape-y” horror films.

That night time, the ladies go to the Orpheum to confront Chip, they usually trick him into telling them what occurred the night time of their assaults: When Tabby rejected him at Karen’s celebration, he left and went to the seashore to chill down, discovering Imogen there handed out, at which level, he raped her as a result of, “[Tabby] did not wish to be with me.” Later, when he discovered Tabby was going to a celebration with soccer gamers, he adopted her to the celebration and found her strolling dwelling drunk, and he raped her too.

What Occurs to Chip?

Imogen and Tabby report Chip to the police for his crimes, and he is arrested. However finally, he is launched round Christmas, as his dad and mom made bail. Nonetheless, the ladies plan to press fees. Nonetheless, he could by no means face justice — no less than not in courtroom. On the finish of the season one finale, “A,” aka Aaron Waters, escapes from the hospital the place he is being held and handled for his stab wounds, at which level he goes to Chip’s home to kill him.

Debunked Fan Theories for Imogen’s Child’s Father


All through the primary 5 episodes, it turns into clear Tyler is a sleazy piece of labor. He was the one who egged Kelly on and filmed her when she was intoxicated and susceptible after discovering out Greg had kissed Imogen at her celebration. Tabby overhears him bragging about having intercourse with somebody and never “pulling out” in episode 4, and he tries to strain Mouse into ingesting. However whenever you think about Tyler’s brutal demise by the hands of “A” on the finish of episode 5, it grew to become clear he wasn’t the daddy.


Greg outright lies about making a transfer on Imogen at Karen’s celebration, placing Imogen in an unimaginable scenario. All through the primary seven episodes, he is haughty and self-centered. Whereas he is not fairly as creepy as Tyler, he isn’t significantly better. He typically crosses the road together with his sexual jokes and advances, like when he stripped bare whereas filming Tabby’s horror movie in episode 5 after having promised to put on a speedo as a part of her safe-set circumstances. Ultimately, this merely wasn’t the case, nonetheless.

Leave a Comment