Homage or Copy? Deborah Roberts Is Suing a Fellow Artist for Allegedly Stealing Her Photocollage Model

Deborah Roberts waited a very long time for recognition. Six years in the past, the 59-year-old artist was working in a shoe retailer when a grant from the Pollock-Krasner Basis allowed her to begin specializing in her artistic follow. Her collage-based portraits of Black kids are actually present in museum collections throughout the US. Sellers additionally observed her expertise, and she or he signed onto the rosters of outstanding galleries Susanne Vielmetter in Los Angeles and Stephen Friedman in London.

Roberts is now seeking to defend her market. In August, she filed a lawsuit claiming that one other collage artist, Lynthia Edwards, and her vendor, Richard Beavers Gallery, had engaged in “willful copyright infringement.” The civil criticism was filed in the US District Courtroom for the Jap District of New York and contains different allegations of commerce costume infringement, unfair competitors, and market dilution.

Roberts is searching for $1 million in damages. She didn’t reply to a request for remark from Artnet Information.

“This isn’t a frivolous declare,” Roberts advised Sightlines, an arts publication. “I would like everybody to achieve success within the artwork world, particularly younger and rising artists of coloration. To say that I punch down at a younger artist is disingenuous.”

A side-by-side of Lynthia Edwards and Deborah Roberts's work, as reproduced in the original complaint.

A side-by-side of Lynthia Edwards and Deborah Roberts’s work, as reproduced within the authentic criticism.

Roberts contends that the issues started after Beavers contacted her in 2020, requesting to point out and promote her artwork. After she declined to work with the gallery, the criticism alleges that “[Beavers] and Lynthia Edwards have considerably copied and supplied on the market … works of visible artwork that replicate the composition, content material, type, framing, coloration, narrative, and inventive intent of Ms. Roberts’ work.”

Moreover, the lawsuit claims that Edwards has been “aggressively marketed” at artwork festivals the place Roberts has additionally proven work, together with Expo Chicago and Untitled Artwork Miami Seaside. The similarities between their types and advertising and marketing resulted in confusion from shoppers, the swimsuit states, citing textual content messages and correspondence from collectors who’ve mistaken Edwards’ work for Roberts’.

Edwards, a 44-year-old artist primarily based in Alabama, has not publicly commented on the lawsuit past an Instagram story the place she holds a mug illustrated with textual content studying, “I’m fantastic.”

In a press release, Roberts’ lawyer Robert W. Clarida mentioned: “Deborah Roberts is enterprise a authorized case relating to copyright infringement and associated claims towards Lynthia Edwards, Richard Beaversm and Richard Beavers Gallery. That is now a matter for the U.S. judicial system to find out.”

Edwards’s lawyer Luke Nikas, who can be representing Richard Beavers Gallery, mentioned that his shoppers plan to countersue Roberts for making false statements to collectors and art-sale platforms. “They’ve claimed, for instance, that they’d a lawsuit pending towards Lynthia once they didn’t, which resulted within the cancellation of Edwards’s place on a outstanding artwork gross sales platform,” Nikas mentioned in an interview with Artnet Information, declining to call which platform.

A side-by-side of Lynthia Edwards and Deborah Roberts's work, as reproduced in the original complaint.

A side-by-side of Lynthia Edwards and Deborah Roberts’s work, as reproduced within the authentic criticism.

“It’s extraordinarily troubling that Deborah Roberts has filed this case,” Nikas added. “She is utilizing her sources and affect to cram down a brand new up-and-coming artist as a result of she perceives her to be a menace to her market. And it’s extraordinarily uncommon for one artist to sue one other artist for working in the identical inventive custom or type.”

Inside his September 21 letter requesting a convention with Decide LaShann DeArcy Corridor to debate a movement to dismiss the lawsuit, Nikas factors out that “the usage of photo-based collage has deep roots within the work of Black artists, and Roberts didn’t invent this inventive custom and doesn’t personal it.” He cited historic examples from figures together with Jacob Lawrence, Romare Bearden, and Benny Andrews.

“Not not like Edwards, these artists additionally discovered inspiration in cultural practices premised on improvisation, resembling quilting and papering partitions with newspaper,” the letter continued. “Edwards has at all times emphasised her place on this lineage of Black collagists and cubists utilizing improvisation, collage, and assemblage.”

Comply with Artnet Information on Fb:

Need to keep forward of the artwork world? Subscribe to our publication to get the breaking information, eye-opening interviews, and incisive crucial takes that drive the dialog ahead.

Leave a Comment